Should I pick up Carmona?

Question

If I did then I would have to drop one of the following:

Josh Johnson: He' been k'ing everyone since he got back from injury

Ricky Nolasco

Manny Parra

Answer 1

well, carmona isnt better than any of the players u just listed, so there really isnt any point in picking him up.  

Answer 2

man, i guess im the only one that hasnt forgotten that carmona was a cy young candidate last year and had the same amount of wins as CC last year (19 wins) he gave a ton of quality starts and he pitched solid except that he screwed up from time to time. he is on a rebuilding team so that will make it hard. i think u have to trade parra since he has trade value and fill another gap in ur team. like a 2 for 1 so u have space for him. the only thing that really matters is if u think he can do as well on a rebuilding team. if the answer is no then just stay away from him.

btw, the reason why i think u should trade parra is cuz he has been horrible in his past few starts and can loose any value left. hope this helps

Answer 3

I guess Liriano isn't good enough to make your team.  He is way better than any of the other guys in your list.  Plus he is 12-2 with AAA, and has massive upside.  Don't make a mistake and not pick him up

Answer 4

The million dollar question.If you look at Carmonas stats even when he was healthy and the only ehing he was good for was wins.He doesnt have a good k ratio,he has an average era and an above average whip.Even if he was healthy he wouldnt give you more than Para or Nolasco.