Should I pickup Favre?

Question

Our fantasy league decided that we would draw numbers to see who gets the first shot of picking up Brett Favre, if he plays again. Well I get the first shot at him. since he is playing should I pick him up?

My current QB's are Peyton Manning, Jason Campbell, and Jay Cutler

I know alot of people don't think Campbell will produce, but I fell differently and I want to keep him, the skins play a lot of teams that pass defenses weren't ranked any higher than 20th last season. So should I drop Cutler?

Answer 1

Its up to you. both qb's are awesome but cutler was impressive last season but so was brett favre with career bests. I think u should drop cutler and get favre

Answer 2

as much as i like cutler you need to and get favre... cutler aint got any weapons around him and he lost brandon marshall for 3 games to start the season. favre to the jets who spent 100 million in the offseason on the o-line and def front 7 so he will be protected and he has good but not great weapons around him...  

Answer 3

I would drop Campbell Cause You never gonna start campbell over manning anyways, and the one bye week Manning has week 4, Id take farve at home against the cardinals, rather than campbell at the cowboy or   jay culter at kansas city.    

Answer 4

Cutler sucks. He is next to worthless.

I don't know how big your league is, but why would you want to carry 3 QBs anyway?

Look man, you have Manning, what more do you need? He will throw 30 + TDs as it is, and he never gets injured.

Don't get caught up in the Favre hype.

He is a 39 yr old man that is going to a completely new offense he has 4 weeks to learn. He also has to find a way to play with an entirely new set of players.

This offensive line gave up 29 sacks last year.

I mean, c'mon, they were 4-12 last season. Do you really think Favre can just walk in there and take them to the Super Bowl?

Don't jump on the Favre bandwagon, he will be on injured reserve by mid season.