Should I pull the trigger on this trade?

Question

I GET:

Miguel Cabrera

& Mark Derosa-good pos. elgibility

HE GETS:

Matt Holiday

I would say i have a legit 3rd baseman with Ryan Zimmerman on the DL, & Aubrey Huff

heres how my team looks

C. Geo Soto

1st Ryan Howard

2nd Dan Uggla-Stud

3rd Aubrey Huff

SS Ryan Theriot

OF Matt Holiday

OF Magglio Ordonez

OF Jacoby Ellsbury

Utill Nate McLOUTH

Utill David Murphy

Bench

Ryan Ludwick,

Jay Bruce

DL Ryan Zimmerman

i could get Derek Jeter outa the deal but i'd have to give up more than Ryan Theriot, prolly David Murphy someone like that he doesnt want any pitchers outa the deal soo

Answer 1

Nah I wouldnt. DeRosa has cooled off. I'd rather have Holliday.

Answer 2

While I still think that Cabrera will hit for a higher AVG & Power during the 2nd half of the season, Holiday is the better player at this point.  Derosa is a good fill in player, who is slumping at this point.

Answer 3

No, Holliday is so much better and he's heating up. So no.