Should I start Darren Mcfadden or Jonathan Stewart?

Question

I need to start one of those players. Which one do you think will put up the most fantasy points?

Answer 1

Mcfadden

Answer 2

I actually would disagree with the majority. Put Stewart in, he's been having a terrific pre-season and putting up good yardage. Stewart has speed and strength. Run DMC has been pretty shaky this pre-season so i dont know how reliable he could be. I'll put it like this:

McFadden = Raiders have S****y blocking for him

Stewart= Titans i think, good blocking, Put him in.

Answer 3

McFadden definately.

Stewart isn't even the starter in CAR.  Deangelo Williams is their #1 RB... that may change later in the year though.

Answer 4

For week one its definitely going to be McFadden because Jonathan Stewart has to face the potent defense of the Chargers and D Mac has to face the Broncos D which doesn't fare that well against the run but Run DMC has to compete with Justin Fargas and i think those two will have to split carries but the clear choice is Darren McFadden.

Answer 5

McFadden has the best long term potential, but his blocking is marginal.  Would have to go strongly with Stewart due to the unreliability and inconsistency of the Oakland offense.

Answer 6

Mc fadden for sure

Answer 7

Start Jonathan Stewart this week and Darren Mcfadden week 2 thru 17

Answer 8

Darren McFadden