Should I start McNabb or Peyton Manning week1?

Question

Shoudl I start McNabb vs STL in week 1 or Peyton Manning vs CHI in week 1 for my fantasy team?

Answer 1

Mcnabb becuase hes against STL D and cause Peyton is sort of hurt right now and hasnt seen any practice.

Answer 2

Peyton Manning.  They play the Bears Week 1, and I have a feeling that him and Marvin Harrison will score like 2 TD's!

Answer 3

Mcnabb because the bears defense will be too tough for Manning. Manning won't have a great game but he won't suck.

Answer 4

I would ALWAYS start manning over anyone else expect Brady and maybe Romo is some spots. You go with the more consistent QB.. simple as that.

Answer 5

The safe thing to do is start Peyton since he has a healthy Marvin Harrison back and other great weapons. BUT he is playing a tough Bears defense. If you start McNabb he might have a huge game against a terrible St. Louis team.

Overall: Go with Manning.

Answer 6

it usually depends on the opponent...but in this situation peyton all the way

Answer 7

start Mcnabb cuz Chicago may shut down the Colts

Answer 8

You play fantasy football and you dont know the answer to this one ??? . . . . . .

Just hang up your team and try again next year

Peyton VS Bears

Comp   Att    Yds     TD   Int

29        17      247     1      1

17         28     211      4     1

26         39     302     2      1

McNabb VS Rams

Comp   Att    Yds     TD   Int

3            3        36      1     0

Did Not play against them in  2002 -injury

32        48        312   2     1

18        30        171   1      1

15        32        179   3      2

McNabb is spotty vs the Rams as you can tell by the games he has played against them, while Manning is pretty solid. McNabb is injury prone and doesnt move well any more. Also when has Manning ever been taken out of a game?? Bears Defense isnt as good as the one that took them to the Super Bowl, and who beat them in the SB?? Manning took apart that defense, and with the bears defense not as good as it was......

Did someone say McNabb always plays good against the rams?? Show me all these "Games" he has played well against them

Answer 9

manning

Answer 10

Well, if I were you I'd start Manning.  Even though he isn't healthy right now, he is the better QB.  McNabb did ok last season, but anytime you have a better QB you always want to start the one with the better passer rating, more yardage, and better completion percentage.  Manning against the Bears should be a win because the bears have nothing offensively and their defense has been the only thing that can carry them, and by no means will the colts high octane offense be stopped by the Bears defense.  Going with Manning is always a better choice..  

Answer 11

chicagos D is tough......and peyton is coming off surgery from the offseason....so he might be a lil shaky...mcnabb is healthy and has something to prove...and STL is getting worse by the season, and thier D was never really a strong point for them...in any other circumstance i would go with peyton, but in this situation i would have to go with mcnabb....

Answer 12

Manning