Should I take this trade, I think I should but I'm an LT hater.

Question

I was offered LaDainian Tomlinson, Ryan Grant, Marion Barber and I would give away Adrian Peterson, Willis McGahee, and Reggie Wayne.

Here is my roster:

QB: Ben Roethlisberger

RB: Adrian Peterson

RB: Steven Jackson

RB/WR: Willis McGahee

WR: Randy Moss

WR:Reggie Wayne

TE:Tony Gonzalez

D: Seahawks

K: Nick Folk

Punter: Andy Lee

Bench: Marques Colston, Chris Cooley, Carson Palmer, Santonio Holmes, Larry Johnson, Mason Crosby, Vikings Defense.

My problem is that I hate LT and love AP and I don't know what receiver I should put in if I accept it.

Thanks

Answer 1

Tell him that he needs to offer a receiver instead of Barber.  

Answer 2

I'd say it's a pretty balanced trade but if anything you're bringing a little more value to your team.  You'll obviously be overloaded with good RB's which is never a bad thing.  You'll need to bring up a WR from your bench to fill in for Wayne, but I think Santonio is going to have a huge year (3 year rule) so he should fill in fine.

Not to mention you have plenty of trade bait if something comes up down the road..

Short answer: go for it.

Answer 3

How'd you get Peterson, Jackson,Mcgahee and Moss?????   But that's besides the point, take the trade...L.T is better than Peterson, Grant is just as good as Mcgahee and Barber is much better than Wayne...Do IT!!!

Answer 4

that is a tough decision. LT and Adrian r the the top 2 fantasy Players period so if u did trade that would not be a big deal. But then it just depends on how much you like Marques Colston because he is your best WR on the bench. And Reggie Wayne is a better receiver then him.  

Answer 5

absolutly not, you would be way overloaded on RB's and underloaded on WR's and Marion is going to be splitting carries even more. No wa in h**l do you make this trade! I am Keeping AP in my league.  

Answer 6

do it...AP is going to have to share playing time w taylor so LT's stats should be better. Same w Barber, he's the cowboys only RB now that they dont have Jones. You can pick any wr thats stable and has a low chance of injury or suspension. nobody like steve smith

Answer 7

dont accept.  your team is stacked as it is

Answer 8

never, ever,draft/trade/pickup/drop players in fantasy based upon your individual likes/dislikes/favorite/hated team. Are you guys in a 4 team league? Seems like you guys like to trade just for the sake of trading. The real test comes during the season when you have to manage your team.

Answer 9

don't do it man.ya need ap and things will soon look up for ya