Question:

Should I tell her the truth?

by  |  earlier

0 LIKES UnLike

I am in love with this girl, Sylvia. I have been in love with her as long as I know her. But she didn't like me. She tolerated me as a friend, but nothing more. I thought that if I was steady and patient, I would win her love by and by. I am an orphan, employed in as a shop-assistant, and rose to be a partner in the business. I was happy to be able to give Sylvia a good life. But she met a man, Charley Kinraid, a sailor, and fell in love with him, and got engaged. He is not a good man. The other junior partner who works with me told me that he was after many women, that he dated his sister, and then dumped her when a better-looking woman came along. I heard stories about his exploits with women. Then one day I saw him being forced into a military navy. He asked me to deliver a message to Sylvia and promised to come back and marry her. I went away on business, and when I came back, Kinraid was believed to drown. They found some of his clothes on the shore. Sylvia is very depressed. But I found out that her neighbour, Bessy Corney, cried after Kinraid as if she were engaged to him, too. I am doing very well for myself, and can offer Sylvia a prosperous future. If I tell her what I witnessed, she will wait for Kinraid and be unhappy and lonely. What should I do?

 Tags:

   Report

7 ANSWERS


  1. Find another woman more deserving of your kindness and devotion.


  2. Oh, my, ny~

    No matter what, you'll feel best in the long run if you tell her the truth. She'll always know your honesty is dependable, such a valuable quality.

    May her eyes open to the gem in front of her.

    Best wishes.

  3. The fact that she knew you before she met him and still fell in love with him means that she wasn't interested in you. Forget about her and move on. She's not for you.

  4. It's book's plot.

    Sylvia's Lovers by Elizabeth Gaskell.

  5. you got the wrong category man....

    hello?? singles and dating

  6. can you start using books i know? you do these a lot and it looks like fun but i cant comment cause i dont know what book its from!

  7. wow dude that's like the saddest thing ever.

    you should tell her. she deserves to know the truth but you should tell her everything else about this guy too, he sounds like a creep.

    then maybe she won't want him anymore.

Question Stats

Latest activity: earlier.
This question has 7 answers.

BECOME A GUIDE

Share your knowledge and help people by answering questions.