Should I trade A-rod straight up for Beltran???

Question

With the playoffs weeks away we all know that Beltron some how transforms himself into Mickey Mantle, Willie Mays & Joe Dimaggio all rolled into one & A-Rod goes into a huge slump. In my fantasy league one guy is offering me Beltran straight up. Will history repeat itself should I dump A-Rod as Beltran will go on fire in the playoffs like he always does?

Answer 1

Yea..... If you want to throw your fantasy season down the DRAIN.

Answer 2

I am a Met's fan and would not make that deal.

Answer 3

Easy answer. A Rod is Hall of Famer, Beltran is not.

Beltran turn into those HOF, hmm…I don’t think so. A-Rod has already done some of records no one has never done before.

Beltran never lived up to his potential anyway ever since get into Mets. A-Rod trade for David Wright plus Beltran or Melfrey is probably a fair trade.

I already under an impression Yankees is the only team can afford A-Rod anyway.

Since we are talking non-sense and as a Braves Fan, I hope both Beltran and A-Rod are in the Braves and they gain profit of 45 mils to afford them.

Answer 4

Heck no A-Rod is a monster in fantasy leagues and Beltran will never live up to the hype.

Answer 5

no easier to replace out field then it is for third base.

Answer 6

no coz wat happens if neither gets in the playoffs

Answer 7

No way! Not this year. I think Arod is more consistent day-to-day than Beltran in my opinion. Although, it also depends on how badly you need an OF if you already have a solid 3B.

Answer 8

lol... a-rod is still a-rod i'm not an a-rod fan and if i had him i wouldn't trade him....

Answer 9

i wont a-rod is way better then beltran

Answer 10

I wouldn't do such trade.  

Answer 11

Coming from a Met fan, no. A-rod always seems to play well in meaningless games. Before you take my advice though, who are your starting outfielders and backup third baseman?

Answer 12

That trade doesn't make any sense.  Beltran is much better with runners in scoring position.  

Answer 13

I personally like carlos beltran an hate a-rod and its not because im a mets fan either i do like derek jeter hes a good ball player i just cant stand what hes doing with Madonna and his personal life plus A-rod is way overated i think beltran could make the hall of fame if he plays a little better