Should I trade? AP (VIK) RB, S Moss WR, Cooley, Seattle for Portis, A Johnson (WR), T. Gonzalez (TE), NE DEF ?

Question

I have: Boldin, Holmes, Driver (WR)

Jacobs, R Williams, D Williams, K Smith (RB)

Manning & Rivers (QB)

J-Ville DEF

Vinateria KICKER

I need a good receiver but he really wants Cooley, Seattle & AP. LET ME KNOW YOUR THOUGHTS

Answer 1

AP is not a Top 5 back, so you come out the same there.

Johnson is a definate step up from Moss.

You are losing on the TEs big time.

DEF are really a wash.

from that info, you decide, but I would probably look for a better trade elsewhere.

Answer 2

Well, currently I wouldn't trade Cooley for Tony G because Tony is getting old and not as mobile and not averaging as many catches as he used too. While Cooley is a sure-fire point provider at your TE spot.  It's tough to trade Peterson after the season he had last year and he's only gonna do basically the same this year and Portis wouldn't be able to fill Peterson's shoes on your team.  I honestly think NE DEF is overrated, Seattle will be the overall better choice. NO DEAL!

Answer 3

no i wouldn't i think ap will have a big year and cooley is just as good as gonzalez

Answer 4

no way. AP is gold,so is Cooley. Johnson is a stud, but he's fragile. only played haif a year last year. keep what you have, and when johnson gets hurt pick up K walter(Hou WR #2)

Answer 5

no dont do it