Should I trade Brandon Phillips for Magglio Ordonez?

Question

I am a Phillips fan but now that the Reds seem so offensively challenged and the Tigers are finding their stride I'm tempted to take this trade. Thoughts?

Answer 1

if you can take an OF for a 2B yea i'd take the trade.  They have had similar season.  Phillips has 2 more runs and 2 more HR than Magglio and Phillips has 14 SB to 0 but Ordonez has more hits a way higher average and more RBI's and more walks