Should I trade C.Palmer and B.Edwards for P. Manning and P. Burress?

Question

Should I trade C.Palmer and B.Edwards for P. Manning and P. Burress?

Answer 1

I would not make this trade.  While Manning is a bit better than Palmer, Edwards is waaaay better than Burress.  Burress is hurt...again AND look at Burress' numbers down the stretch last year.  While he came out of the gate guns ablazin' he was pretty pedestrian the rest of the way.  Of his last 11 games, he only broke 100 yards once and had 7 games with less than 50 yards receiving.  In Edward's last 8 games he scored a TD in all but 2.  

Don't do it.

Answer 2

It sounds like a good trade. Peyton always has a solid game and I think Plaxico is a good WR. Edwards is second only to TO in dropped balls.

Just be careful with Peyton's injury (knee). They say he's recovering well from surgery, but just make sure! And you'll want to keep an eye on Burress's ankle.

Answer 3

That's a pretty good trade on paper. It seems solid and fair for both sides.

Peyton will score 5 mroe points a game than Palmer and Edwards will prob do the same compared to Burress. But I've never been on the Burress bandwagon. I think he's too fragile. He doesn't go over the middle much and I really doubt he'll go off for 25 points any weeks this year. While Edwards definately will. He'll ahve his 2 touchdown and 100 yard games.

I personally would stick with Palmer and Edwards, but if you took the trade I'd understand. But one other thing. Peyton should have been available when you picked up Edwards, wasn't he? And if you chose Edwards over Manning and still ended up with Palmer, I think you should stick with that.

Answer 4

It looks pretty even to me.  I would do it.  You know you can depend on Manning and Burress is a solid #1 WR.  Palmer and Edwards are both good but I think there is more question marks with both of them.

Answer 5

I like that trade... Manning shouldn't lose his step this year and he alone is worth the trade. Edwards and Burress are an even trade, but Manning makes this worthwhile. I'd make the trade...

Answer 6

I use http://www.freefantasyhelp.com

I get stats, draft guides... all types of good stuff

Check it out its free!!!