Question:

Should I trade Eli Manning and Aaron Rodgers for Donovan McNabb?

by  |  earlier

0 LIKES UnLike

my starting qb is peyton manning, and eli has the same bye week as peyton

 Tags:

   Report
Answer The Question I've Same Question Too

10 ANSWERS

Sort By: Date  |  Rating

  1. ARE U CRAZY NO WAY


  2. Eli has SB confidence...Aaron Rodgers should be very good...and McNabb is an overrated injury prone player...what has McNabb ever done that's great besides choke in the SB...

  3. No. How many points do you think McNabb is going to put up per ganme in that lackluster mediocre offense?  Not much.

  4. No not for both but maybe one or the other.

  5. If you already have peyton as your starter dealing these two Qb's make sense, not only do you return a top ten fantasy QB (the people above have no idea what they are talking about) but you open up a roster spot you were wasting on holding 3 qb's.... yes Mcnabb has been injured the past few years but its the NFL and Qb's are bound to go down at some point.. .unless you are brady, manning, or favre.. chances are you missed some time over the past few seasons... Mcnabb has potential to return to fantasy glory with the addition of his much missed tighend LJ smith... and regardless with brian westbrook in the passing game mcnabb will put up numbers... also look for rookie deshaun jackson to finally be the vertical threat they have been looking for in philly... his big play potential only adds to mcnabbs potential... and finally mcnabb is using this year to make a statement he has been injured and subject to trade talks look for him to have an impact year... all of this potential for a back up QB... looks like you got a deal and use your extra roster spot to find that sleeper FA you might have been reluctant to pick up earlier

  6. No..not worth 2 QBs

  7. no no no... Donovan is on the outs

  8. nope and why did you pick aaron he is not good

  9. Play two running backs on the bye week to compensate.  Eli alone will have better year end stats than Donovan (...but why on earth did you take Rodgers - even as a bench warmer).

    So no, pass on that trade.

  10. Are you on crack? heelllll no
You're reading: Should I trade Eli Manning and Aaron Rodgers for Donovan McNabb?

Question Stats

Latest activity: earlier.
This question has 10 answers.

BECOME A GUIDE

Share your knowledge and help people by answering questions.
Register Now