Question:

Should I trade Eli Manning and Roddy White for Wes Welker?

by Guest33207  |  earlier

0 LIKES UnLike

my starting QB is peyton manning and i have aaron rodgers as my backup... eli has the same bye week as peyton, so that's why i wanna trade him... and my other two WR are T.O. and reggie wayne

 Tags:

   Report
Answer The Question I've Same Question Too

9 ANSWERS

Sort By: Date  |  Rating

  1. Keep roddy white unless you can get another big time guy but trade eli.  


  2. NO h**l NO

  3. No way dude, Wes Welker had a good year last year but it was because of the offense, not his skills as a player. Sure he is quite good, but not good enough to give up Eli and Roddy for him. Check your league and look for someone who is weak at QB, and send him a few requests for a better player for Eli, if he is desperate enough, im sure he will give in to what you want in return

  4. No you can get something better then that. Wes Welker was a product of his enviroment. he played the slot and was matched up with someone not suited to cover him. Now that he is the #2 guy and not the #3 guy anymore he wont have the same coverage mismatches and he wont do near as good as he did last year.

    To the guy below me "Fletch" not sure why you think Welker will only have a SS on him. What is the other CB doing sitting on the bench? Welker will have a starting corner on him and he wont do near as good

  5. I'd go with it if you can find a decent QB in free agency. Why would you pick Aaron Rodgers? That's........ I won't say it.

    If you have T.O. and Reggie you can afford to lose Roddy. With Stallworth out the picture teams are going to put a linebacker and a FS on Moss leaving only a SS to cover Welker whom he'll burn.

    I'd look into your FA and see if you can get a servicable QB to replace Eli. Trent Edwards and Troy Smith are around in alot of leagues and will put up numbers similar to Eli's.

    I'd take that gamble. You have to factor in who's Roddy White's QB...

  6. Don't do that, and even if you wanna, then only give Eli and not also Roddy.

    If I were you I would go for Steve Smith (Carolina), Braylon Edwards, or Andre Johnson (Andre is my favorite fanatsy receiver)

    P.S. How tha h**l you get TO, Reggie, and Peyton, I wana know your secret.

  7. no way!

    keep the Manning Brothers together! who knows? they might surpise you in the game

  8. h**l NOOOOO!!!!!!!!

  9. No.
You're reading: Should I trade Eli Manning and Roddy White for Wes Welker?

Question Stats

Latest activity: earlier.
This question has 9 answers.

BECOME A GUIDE

Share your knowledge and help people by answering questions.
Register Now