Should I trade Eli Manning or Jason Campbell for Donovan McNabb??

Question

Which one should I trade for him?

Answer 1

If the guy is ignorant enough to do it, trade Campbell for him.  Eli, while looking pathetic during the regular season last year, may get better and still has WRs to throw to.

Answer 2

Stick a fork in Mcnabb hes done. He may play a couple more seasons but he will not put up any consistant fantasy numbers for you.

Answer 3

I would keep McNabb, but I am biased because I have had him on my roster in previous years. I think Campbell could have a good year, but that is a gamble. Manning should put up the same amount of points as McNabb unless one of the other is injured.

Answer 4

Try Campbell first if the other person doesn't go for it...then try Eli...be careful...McNabb is injury prone.

Answer 5

You should keep both and forget about McNabb.  Jason Campbell could be a top ten QB this year.  The redskins went out and got him a bunch of weapons this off-season and with the taylor trade they just upgraded the D as well.  McNabb has become a name recognition player that always carries inflated fantasy value.(i.e.-overrated)  The only way you should do this is if you can turn around and flip McNabb for an even better Qb.  Good luck this season.