Should I trade Johan or Dan Haren for Josh Hamilton?

Question

My pitching is pretty set and my OF is kinda weak (Ordonez, Damon, Drew, Tavares)

My pitching is Dice K, Johan, Hudson, Dan Haren, and some other OK to good SP.

Answer 1

Hamilton hit .327/12/61 in April/May (55 games)  and .284/8/37 since June 1 (40 games). It looks to me that he is tailing off after a hot start so giving up a quality SP for him should not even be considered.

If you're going to trade Santana or Haren do it in a deal that doesn't include a fading former crackhead turned Jesus freak.

Answer 2

Yes, I would trade Santana or Haren for Hamilton.  Pitchers only help you twice a scoring period, maximum, while Hamilton will produce elite numbers every day of the week.

Answer 3

I would trade Haren for Hamilton if you can. Hamilton might be the best fantasy  baseball player. He drives in runs, has a high average, scores a lot of runs and hits many home runs.

Answer 4

I would trade Haren for Hamilton.