Should I trade Jonathon Stewart for Fred Taylor?

Question

Should I trade Jonathon Stewart for Fred Taylor?

Answer 1

no

Answer 2

I would say no.

Fred had a good injury free year...........but that was just one good year

Hopefully he can continue that impressive season last year....but going on his past history.......don't push your luck

Answer 3

Excellent question. At this point I would trade Stewart for Taylor. Taylor made it through last season without a serious injury but 2008 is a new year. Never trust a rookie RB until at least week 3 to see the numbers. Rookie RB's are going to be plentiful especially this year ( keep an eye on Forte )

To much riding on Stewart. I've cut him twice in auto draft leagues and picked up Andre Hall who has an average of 4 yds per carry as my back up.

Take a look at Ray Rice in Baltimore too. He just might take over the starting position in Baltimore.

Answer 4

no

Answer 5

Yes, I would trade Stewart, unproven rookie, sharing time with DeAngelo Williams for Fred Taylor, sharing time with Maurice Jones-Drew.  

Answer 6

yes...a rookie for a pro bowler? dude.