Should I trade Mccann and David Wright for Arod, Chone Figgins and Ryan Doumit?

Question

Answer fast- i need to accept/reject the deal by tonight!

I would upgrade on both 2b and 3b but I would drop significantly on the catcher position. Also, Figgins and Doumit are pretty injury prone and Doumit does not get a 100% playing time. Any thoughts...

Answer 1

Yes, I would do it. A-Rod is really playing well right now and will be a great player to have if you need some hitting. Figgins is also a good second baseman even though he might get injured, and Doumit has really good offensive numbers for a catcher. McCann is a spectacular catcher, but I think it's worth it to sacrifice one position to get two other positions you need.

Answer 2

i think it's an easy decision- i'd pull the trigger. Doumit is coming off a concussion, not abnormal for a catcher, but still somewhat flukish. if both he & McCann stay healthy and play the rest of the season, i don't think McCann outperforms him by all that much. upgrading at 3rd more than makes up for it, and getting Figgins is a bonus. a HUGE bonus, as he hits for average, SBs, and scores runs. i think you get a good deal.

Answer 3

No duh, a rod is the best, figgins is good, doumit sucks, mccans great and wright is stinkin just do it cause of arod.

Answer 4

Arod and Chone are worth it by themselves... Doumit is the #1 catcher for pits with decent numbers .. he had a mild concussion and has been out this week, suppose to start tonight .. regardless u can always get a catcher that produces...  DO IT!!!