Should I trade Peyton Manning and Chester Taylor for LenDale White and Romo?

Question

Advice from common sense and not from your heart please...

Answer 1

No way! You have the better QB in this. Romo is good but peyton is better. People are doubting peyton because of his injury, but watch out. He always has a big year

Answer 2

I'd say no. The only things that scares me a little is Peyton's injury but if he is healthy he should outscore or be close enough to Romo. The Cowboys also run a lot more than the Colts. While Chester Taylor will be playing behind Peterson (who has had some knee problems) LenDale is the type of guy you can pick up off free agency in week 4 when whoever has him realizes he'll never be any good.

I would pass unless you can get something better than White.

Answer 3

While Romo and Manning are both QB studs, Romo had the better year last year and faces an easier schedule this year.  Manning has that slight knee injury and is missing two starters on his offensive line.  I think Romo is a slight upgrade over Manning.

The RBs is where it gets interesting.  Lendale White had a breakout year last year and even though he has Chris Johnson to contend with, he will still get all the goal line carries.  Chester Taylor is a great handcuff to AP and with his upright running style, AP is susceptible to injuries.  However, right now, Lendale White will give you a lot more points week in and week out.  The Risk/Reward is a lot higher with Taylor while with Lendale you know what you'll get.

The point is, if you have RB depth and you'd use White as a #3/#4 backup, I'd hold onto Chester Taylor.  However, if you're struggling at RB and need a week in and week out starter, I'd go with White as you don't have the luxury of hoping that AP gets hurt.  

Answer 4

h**l YEA NO QUESTION....taylor doesnt even start ..so go ahead and do it but ....if ap goes down ull be prreeeettyyyyy upset

Answer 5

tough one.  I you want to play it safe...trade and get a healthy QB to start the season.  On the other hand, I think peyton and chester have more value with a little more risk--though, manning looks to be fine so this may be a nonissue?

Romo needs another career year to match what manning has done every season of his life...and chester becomes a stud back with one twisted knee.

Stick with your current team

Answer 6

Yes I think Romo will be as good if not better this year than  peyton.  DO it