Should I trade Scott Kazmir and Brian Roberts for Erik Bedard and Chipper Jones?

Question

Should I trade Scott Kazmir and Brian Roberts for Erik Bedard and Chipper Jones? My roster is:

C Jorge Posada

1B Ryan Howard

2B Brian Roberts

3B Jorge Cantú

SS Jimmy Rollins

OF Jason Bay

OF Willy Taveras

OF Jay Bruce

Util Adrián Béltre

BN Grady Sizemore

BN Víctor Martínez

DL Ryan Zimmerman

SP Joe Saunders

SP Manny Parra

RP Brandon Lyon

RP Kevin Gregg

P C.J. Wilson

P Justin Verlander

P Johan Santana

BN Scott Kazmir

BN Todd Wellemeyer

P.S. I think that third basemen are easy to come by but there aren't alot of great second basemen.

Thanks for your help!

Answer 1

as long as bedard stays in Seattle it isnt worth it tru chipper jones is good however other than chase utley the second base postion is weak thus making robberts valuable and kazmir and the devil rays are doing amazing so i say NO DEAL

Answer 2

Don't do it! Kazmir is very valuable. In fact the most valuable on your pitching staff. You can trade him for so much more than Chipper Jones. Oh and you're also giving up Roberts who's like an awesome fantasy player. Bedard is practically worthless at this point. So your basically trading Kazmir and Roberts for Chipper.....terrible trade

Answer 3

Nope. Even though Chipper Jones is batting up a storm Bedard hasn't been healthy and neither has Jones. Scott Kazmir and Brian Roberts haven't been injured lately so I would keep what you have.

Answer 4

maybe yes would help you. Chipper is a top fantasy player in all formats and catagory settings. Is he going to be hot all year prob not but Kazmir is known for the DL. I would say this is a no brainer on this one. What I would do is package Johan and Beltre for Utley or soemthing like that. Roberts numbers have not been that great anyway. I say no way you don't take chippper jones and your not giving up very much for him. Remember Cantu and Beltre won't stay hot forever. Also Drop Zimmerman for God Sakes and Put Vmart on the DL.