Should I trade V. Gurrero, C. Beltran, Francisco Rodriguez & Carlos Lee for ARod? Is that giving up too much?

Question

My free agent outfielders (C. Quinton, McClouth, Ellsbury) are outperforming my top draft choices.

Do you think this is giving up too much though?

Answer 1

are you serious? thats way too much. thats a rediculous trade. even if that trade was accepted, it would be vetoed immediately by the league.

Answer 2

Yes arod is way over rated try picking up free agents

Answer 3

do not trade these people..the FAs will slow down...and arod isnt going to be the mvp again

Answer 4

WAYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY TOO MUCH...

Answer 5

Yes, it's too much. First of all, none of your free agent pick ups have put together a full strong season in their career and there's still a lot of season left. They are unproven and there's a good chance at least one will tail off in a big way as the year progresses, so I'd keep at least one proven OF just in case. Personally, I think Quentin and Ellsbury will stay pretty strong, but McLouth will tail off.

Answer 6

Way to much!

Answer 7

Do not do this trade. It is too much. You are losing a lot of valuable plaeyrs, even K-Rod. Come on, man. Youre smarter than this!! :) DO NOT DO THIS TRADE.