Should Jonathon Broxton be removed from his role as closer?

Question

He hasnt looked comfortable in the role and his blown a few saves lately. He's still young but right now I think his role as a set up man is better suited for him. Until Saito returns I think Kuo should be our closer. What do you think?

Answer 1

Yea. He is a way better Set-up guy. He throws hard and the 9th innings isn't always easy for the Dodgers when he's in it.  

Answer 2

I think Broxton is fine as he is.  Kuo's been struggling for some games as well.

For now, Broxton is allright.

Answer 3

I would stick with Broxton for the time being!!

Answer 4

I thought about it but, realistically, Broxton got the stuff and potential of a great closer. He's still a young pitcher in the Major League (at least by experience as a closer) and the move from being set-up man to closer probably caught him off guard. So far, Kuo has better control than Broxton and a nastier slider. For now, Kuo should be the closer until Broxton learn how to control his pitches. He keep walking his hitters which is an absolute no-no for any closer. Like you said, once he learn to settle down and put his pitches in the strike zones, he'll be good.

Answer 5

Unfortunately, the Dodgers don't really have any alternatives right now.  The bullpen has been their strength, but is clearly fatigued and in a collective slump.  If anything, I'd be willing to see Torre just go with the "hot hand."