Should MLAs, MPs seats should be reserved as per caste census in India?

Question

http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/b/bc/PopulationEstimations.jpg

52% for OBC

22.5% for SC/ST

22.5% for Others

Answer 1

Reservations based on caste are wrong, they should be based on economic status, backwardness of a region etc.

Caste is a wrong indicator of reservations as many reserved caste today were rulers in past. For eg. Yadav's are descendants of Krishna who were rulers.

So are many Bhills as well as Jats.

Answer 2

No Never. Until this short of practice is stopped, we INDIAN can not develop our integrity & sovergnity in right way.

Answer 3

Yes, this must be done.These so called Messiahs of the SC/ST/OBC should amend the Constitution of the country and also amend the Pepople's Representation Act immediately to show that what they preach....they practise the same.These hypocrites won't do it.They want Reservations as a tool to have their vote banks and not for development of the country nor for the development and elightenment of the OBC/SC/ST.

If they have they have little sense of honesty in them , they must do the needful to have Reservation in both the Houses of the Parliament of India.The corrupt lot will never do it, I bet.

God Bless

Answer 4

Certain constituency for Parliaments, state assemblies and even panchayat elections are reserved for SC/ST candidates, so reservations already exists in elections.