Should Micheal Vaughan come back as the captain of the England ODI team?

Question

Collingwood has lost 2 ODI series against the kiwis, and Vaughan has won 2 test series against the same side?

Answer 1

no he is a poor batsmen and lacks the ability of captaincy

Answer 2

I don't believe so, he is not suited to ODIs

Answer 3

No, Collingwood is much better than Vaugan.

Answer 4

He is not comfortable playing the shorter version of cricket and he had voluntarily stepped down so the Q of come back is a remote possibility,

Answer 5

i dont think so.He may not be a goodODI players and he feels this also that why he retired from ODIs

Answer 6

no

Answer 7

nooooooooooooooooooo. hes not a good odi player. n y collingwood should replace?

Answer 8

I agree with EDGE.

Answer 9

O.D.I is all about fast running, furious hitting & lightning fielding. M.Vaughan is a perfect test player, but isn't suited to mark himself ''again'', in the O.D.I's........ He is performing very well in tests, odi isn't for him now.

EDIT------------ Captaincy, well I always wanted K.Pietersen to be the skipper of the O.D.I & T20 English team. Collingwood's presence in the team would give moral support as well as strength to the national team. Without captaincy Collingwood may concentrate more on his all-round performance.

Answer 10

Na not at all .Look at his dismissal in the 1st test against South Africa. You cant carry that form into a ODI series. Collingwood brings a younger more enthusiatic feel to the team. He is a better fielder and quicker between the wickets. And he is a great medium pace bowler.

Answer 11

Michael Vaughan has dodgy knees.  Most players that get to MV's venerable age and want to continue playing usually give up ODI.