Question:

Should a 9yr old be banned from play because he has near adult skill?

by  |  earlier

0 LIKES UnLike

9-Year-Old Boy Told He’s Too Good To Pitch

NEW HAVEN, Conn. - Nine-year-old Jericho Scott is a good baseball player — too good, it turns out. The right-hander has a fastball that tops out at about 40 mph. He throws so hard that the Youth Baseball League of New Haven told his coach that the boy could not pitch any more. When Jericho took the mound anyway last week, the opposing team forfeited the game, packed its gear and left, his coach said.

Officials for the three-year-old league, which has eight teams and about 100 players, said they will disband Jericho's team, redistributing its players among other squads, and offered to refund $50 sign-up fees to anyone who asks for it. They say Jericho's coach, Wilfred Vidro, has resigned.

But Vidro says he didn't quit and the team refuses to disband. Players and parents held a protest at the league's field on Saturday urging the league to let Jericho pitch.

"He's never hurt any one," Vidro said. "He's on target all the time. How can you punish a kid for being too good?"

The controversy bothers Jericho, who says he misses pitching.

"I feel sad," he said. "I feel like it's all my fault nobody could play."

Jericho's coach and parents say the boy is being unfairly targeted because he turned down an invitation to join the defending league champion, which is sponsored by an employer of one of the league's administrators.

Jericho instead joined a team sponsored by Will Power Fitness. The team was 8-0 and on its way to the playoffs when Jericho was banned from pitching.

"I think it's discouraging when you're telling a 9-year-old you're too good at something," said his mother, Nicole Scott. "The whole objective in life is to find something you're good at and stick with it. I'd rather he spend all his time on the baseball field than idolizing someone standing on the street corner."

League attorney Peter Noble says the only factor in banning Jericho from the mound is his pitches are just too fast.

"He is a very skilled player, a very hard thrower," Noble said. "There are a lot of beginners. This is not a high-powered league. This is a developmental league whose main purpose is to promote the sport."

Noble acknowledged that Jericho had not beaned any batters in the co-ed league of 8- to 10-year-olds, but say parents expressed safety concerns.

"Facing that kind of speed" is frighteneing for beginning players, Noble said.

League officials say they first told Vidro that the boy could not pitch after a game on Aug. 13. Jericho played second base the next game on Aug. 16. But when he took the mound Wednesday, the other team walked off and a forfeit was called.

League officials say Jericho's mother became irate, threatening them and vowing to get the league shut down.

"I have never seen behavior of a parent like the behavior Jericho's mother exhibited Wednesday night," Noble said.

Scott denies threatening any one, but said she did call the police.

League officials suggested that Jericho play other positions, or pitch against older players or in a different league.

Local attorney John Williams was planning to meet with Jericho's parents Monday to discuss legal options.

"You don't have to be learned in the law to know in your heart that it's wrong," he said. "Now you have to be punished because you excel at something?"

http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20080825/ap_on_sp_ba_ne/bby_too_good_to_pitch;_ylt=Ag5AB7GgJvlylvKn28V7hkADW7oF

 Tags:

   Report

18 ANSWERS


  1. No he not be banned


  2. No. I can see why some of the parents are worried to let their kids play with a 9 year old that throws 50 mph, but you cant punish the kid and ban him from playing because he is too good. What kind of message does that send kids today? You are too good at something so you can no longer do it? Its crazy. The kid has extreme talent, and could be a major leaguer some day with the arm he has, and that  league or community is going to mess him up. Its a shame.

  3. When I was 10 I threw really hard and averaged 14 strikeouts a game -- glad there weren't any parents like this in my league! :-)

    If they have a problem with above-average kids pitching, why don't they have some sort of innings-per-week restriction or something like that so that the kids don't pitch as much? The 11-12 year-old league my son plays in has two rules: you can only pitch so many innings in a week and the pitching has to be split between the age groups. Meaning you might have a kid that is really dominant, but he only pitches a couple of innings each game and most of the game ends up being thrown by pitchers that are fairly average.

    But really, after reading several different versions of the story, I think it has a lot less to do with how good of a pitcher this kid is and more to do with some behind-the-scenes political stuff between parents.

  4. exactly

    it may not be adult skill,but he shouldnt be banned from pitching just because he plays well

  5. yeah um... not really near adult.... 40 mph still is a wayys to go. But I think he definitely does not deserve to be banned

  6. The kid should have never been banned. This a is crock of c**p.

  7. I have a strong feeling that there is a dynamic going on there that we aren't aware of. It's probably a parents' thing rather than this kid. The only flaw in the Little League idea is that parents are involved at all. Adults -- fine. Parents -- banned. Or should be. I'll bet a couple million that what's really going on isn't being reported.


  8. I wouldnt say that was anywhere near adult skill but it sad either way. Im guessing that this league isnt all that good and thats why there is such a problem with this kid pitching. My little brother is 8 and plays rec ball, throws the same if not harder and it really isnt a problem around here. Watching him play in his league and taking what ive seen from when i played, it is not uncommon to see players who are far more physically gifted than others in their age group. The league and the parents of other players need to suck it up because talent happens everywhere, what sense would it make to ban all the great players or make them play harder age groups where they might lose their chance to develop into something truly great just for the sake of pleasing soem parents.Anyways, I think the real story here is the fact that he turned down the offer from the best team and that there wasnt a problem until the little ace started to carry his team to the top of the league.

  9. i hate when people make their questions so long!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! do they think people actually want to read all that? i only read about a paragraph and think that if it is true, it sucks for the kid.

  10. I would like to point at that this is not an actual "little league" league. Like ones sanctioned through The National Little League association in Williamsport PA. It is a youth baseball league, sounds like a rec league that does not know what they are doing. No the kid should not be banned for throwing well. The thing is 40 mph is not really that hard for the 9-10 yr old age. It's on the higher end of average, but not exceptional. From what I read the boy was asked to join the #1 team in the league and refused. And that this is all backlash from that. I do hope the league has some sort of pitching restriction rules. Be they pitch count or innings per week. so this boy does not throw his arm out.  

  11. Near adult skill?  My grandma can throw underhanded this fast.

    40-50 mph is average for 9-10 year olds.  55 is fast.  60 is bringing some heat.

  12. That is a slap on the face of baseball in any level of skill. The kid is not a "ringer", because he's within his own age group and he is not breaking any rules of baseball to warrant his getting disqualified from play.

    Just because he's probably a pitching prodigy, it scares the parents and opposing coaches do death having someone that is capable of striking out his opponents at will with his devastating fast ball.

    It's typical that whatever is not "normal" will scare people and fearful of his skill at such a young age. It's just a matter of the opposition eliminating someone that can truly play the sport. He should be reinstated to play.


  13. Near adult skill?

    That is the funniest thing I heard all day,

    He does have a good gift, but not nearly as good as an Adult.


  14. I don't think he should be kept from playing. I never joined little league, but I understand there are different levels. If this kid is too good for the level he was enrolled in, the league should at least offer to put him in the next higher level. The kid will still be playing and learning at an accelerated rate that will just make him better as he gets older.

  15. Its not adult skill, he is a skill player  but no he shouldnt be ban

  16. this is kinda cool. this is the 12th time this question has been asked.

    the other kids need to practice more and maybe they can compete...or their parents need to stop complaining and let them play and maybe they will get better

  17. Sounds like baseball politics to me. Think about it. The kid is a great pitcher, a great team tries to recruit him, he says no, then kid is banned from pitching. This is all a bunch of bullshit and if i was his parent i would stop at nothing to make sure he can pitch. I smell a lawsuit coming.

  18. It really is unfair.  They should be proud at how good he is.  If he's this good now, just imagine how great he'd be in Major League Baseball some day!

Question Stats

Latest activity: earlier.
This question has 18 answers.

BECOME A GUIDE

Share your knowledge and help people by answering questions.
Unanswered Questions