Should all rapists be Neutered in the U.S.A.?

Question

Neutered= Removing the testis/Balls from a man.

Answer 1

no b.c some people are falsely accused or stat rape

Answer 2

Neutering may not stop the person from doing it again though.  You just prevent them from impregnating their victim.

Answer 3

YES!!!!!!!!!!!

Answer 4

Ha ha, what a funny idea. That's totally fair. But it would be considered as cruel/inhumane/unusual punishment and be against the constitution. How I wish it could happen, though!

Answer 5

Whether they should or not is immaterial since we have a clause in the Bill of Rights against cruel or unusual punishment.

Answer 6

No, because like someone said, some people are falsly accused. I watched a true life crime show awhile back about a man who was sentenced to life in prison for raping and killing a woman.. years later, new evidence came in, another man confessed, and what do ya know, he didn't do it! Cops can make it look like ANYONE committed ANY crime if they really want to.

.. also, it really is rather cruel.. Jail time, sure, but neutering them? No, it's going a step too far.

Answer 7

This should go under Law & Ethics.