Should england's try should have been allowed?

Question

]=

Answer 1

Although I wanted England to lose the try was legitimate. Saw it from 8 different angles on TV and 7 were inconclusive and the 8th showed the English player to have his leg up and knee still in play clearly enough to award the try. Dickinson is a terrible ref. Said this for years. Another classic example of it. Wouldnt have made a l**k of difference though as the boks were clearly the better side.

Answer 2

toe hit the line then went up. ball touched down then knee hit.

not try. unfortunate but good defending. only real opportunity of the game so didn't deserve to win. SA had all the class

Answer 3

well the ref was c**p

Answer 4

I don't think so - his foot went into touch before the ball was grounded. In fact, the piece of turf that was dislodged by his foot actually had white on it.

Congratulations to South Africa, and well done to England for a brilliant effort.

Answer 5

Yes, it was a fair try, the ref was biased.

Answer 6

herbert s

then back to south africa you belong

as Anne Robinson would say" you ARE the weakest link, goodbye"!

Good game though, England should have been given that penalty, but we did 'give away' too many.

Never mind lads, I for one are very very proud of you for getting so far.

Answer 7

No it shouldn't and it wasn't. And they didn't win in anything, spirit or otherwise!

Answer 8

i think so but that french t**t didnt think the same did he!!!

Answer 9

Yes!

Answer 10

English lesson for you Herbert. You are a c**t!

Anyway, all that happened was South Africa played our rugby better than us today. If the try had been given (which it should have been) then things might have been different.

Answer 11

No ya lost ya LOSERS

Answer 12

I am South African!!!!

FOR ALL BRITISH PEOPLE ( SCOTTISH;ENGLISH; WELSH AND NORTHERN IRISH)

UK IS A LOSER COUNTRY!!!!!

SORRY FOR MY ENGLISH I AM AN AFRIKAAN SPEAKER!

Answer 13

NO TRY!!!! FOR LOSERS

Answer 14

still would of made no difference even tho i thought it was a try.The ref was to inconsistent.but the boks did deserve to win