Should i accept this offer???

Question

heres my team

10 team league

QB-P Manning

WR-Wayne

WR- A Johnson

WR- S Holmes

RB- J Lewis

RB-McFadden

TE-Gates

K-Gostkowski

D-Steelers

B-J Stewart

B- S Young

B-A Rodgers

B- J Cotchery

B- S Rice

B-DeAngelo Williams

he offered me Portis

i give him A.Johnson, Stewart, and S. Young....

accept or reject??

Answer 1

Those are 2 really solid backup RB's you have on your bench in Stewart and Young. Upgrading to Portis would be useless since you already have 2 good starters there.

One thing I'd try to do is package those 2 for a receiver (think Houshmanzadeh or Roy Williams caliber) to replace Holmes in your starting lineup.

If you can't find anyone to bite just yet, wait til after week 1 when they have good games and *then* trade them for your WR.  

Answer 2

Sounds like a bad deal.  Reject.

Answer 3

Reject it

Answer 4

He's asking  for too much.

Counter with Johnson  and Young  only....if he  likes, do it

Answer 5

no thats a ripoff. give him stewart and young if he wants more players than that its a ripoff

Answer 6

h**l YERR

Answer 7

reject.

Portis will get alot of touches, but AJ and Stewart are too valuable ... Selvin is decent because Den RBs usually get 1000 yards a season but they are more or less by committee out there.