Should i drop matt cain for sonnanstine (TB)?

Question

My pitching staff:

Matt Cain

Ricky Nolasco

Andy Pettitte

Jair Jurrjens

Joe Saunders

Felix Hernandez

Shaun Marcum

RP:

Jose Valverde

Joe Nathan

Brian Wilson

Jon Rauch

Francisco Cordero

Answer 1

I have Cain in several leagues. He is hot and cold plus gets little run support from his bad team.Andy plitches for the team with the best record in baseball.

Tough call, but I would probably do it. Now, are you certain that it is Cain that you need to drop? I suggest that you review your roster one more time and perhaps there is somebody else that is not contributing.

Good luck. Have fun.

Answer 2

no . have you seen some of the other pitchers on your staff or have you ever seen Cain pitch he is nasty

Answer 3

Yes, sonnanstine is on the best team in baseball and keeps winning. Cain gave up 5 runs on Sunday. He is not consistent!!!!!

Answer 4

no you should not,  Cain is a proven quality starter.  Sonnanstine will cool down

Answer 5

Keep Cain he strikes more people out and pitches in a better stadium he has just been unlucky with his wins so far.  Sonnanstine is a back of the rotation guy who could be released if the Rays bring up top prospect David Price.