Should i play matt schaub or eli manning?

Question

Should i play matt schaub or eli manning?

Answer 1

You have to go with the proven commodity in Manning over the rookie inexperience in Schaub. Good luck to him adjusting to the NFL in the ATL...

Answer 2

Pittsburgh will be tough on Schaub.  Go with manning.

Answer 3

Eli.... because Schaub will be under fire all day from the Steelers.  

Answer 4

First off don't answer question if you have no idea what you are talking about!!!! Second I would go with Matt Schaub he has great talent around him and was putting up monster numbers when he was healthy last year.

Answer 5

Schaub without a doubt.

Granted, Eli did win the Superbowl, but during the 2007 regular season he had the 25th worse passer rating in the NFL and tied for the most interceptions (20).

Schaub has a top 5 WR in Andre Johnson not to mention Kevin Walter and Owen Daniels are also great targets.  Schaub is also very quick on his feet and has the ability to rush for TDs. Schaub is a great sleeper in 2008.  If you want to learn more about Andre Johnson, check out his stats here: http://www.sportsline.com/nfl/players/pl...