Should i take this trade

Question

I get fitz and steven jackson i give randy moss and ronnie brown

Answer 1

No, it is ok but Brown was tearing it up before he got hurt last year and Jackson did not play consistently last year.

Answer 2

I wouldn't do it just for the sake of trading. While I think the offer is fair, Brown remains a question in my mind. Can he come back after his injury and what effect will Ricky Williams return have. Another thing to consider is that backs will be used by committee by most teams this year so the receivers is the part of the offer you should consider most.

Answer 3

I would take it. Jackson gets you lots of total yards and has potential for more TD's. Moss won't repeat last year, but will still star. I think Moss is less of an upgrade over Fitz than Steven Jackson is over Ronnie Brown, i.e. Fitz + Jackson > Moss + Brown. Plus, Brown is coming off over a season-ending injury and that Dolphin offense is terrible and still has no supporting cast for Ronnie.  

Answer 4

Yeah, Randy Moss is the best WR in the NFL, but it is really unrealistic to expect him to repeat his performance last year. Ronnie Brown is coming off a serious knee injury, not to mention he plays for the Dolphins.

With Fitzgerald you get a top 5 WR, and with Stephen Jackson you get a top 5 RB. Both of those guys are guaranteed to produce big numbers for you. Steven Jackson should be back at 100% health after being injured for quite a bit of last season.

So yes, make this trade, even though your team loses Randy Moss, you almost even that loss out with Fitzgerald, and then with the addition of Jackson, I believe you come out with the better deal in this trade.

Answer 5

do it

steven jackson is a top 5 pick

and i had L fitz last year and he was amazing. moss wont top or even match what he did last year so thats a good deal for you

Answer 6

If Ronnie Brown is a starter on your team, take it, plane and simple.  Ronnie will be splitting carries with Ricky and coming off a serious injury, so dont expect great numbers.  

There's 2 ways to look at the trade:

1.  The upgrade you will recieve at runningback will be larger than the downgrade at wide receiver.

2.  Jackson goes higher than moss and Fitz goes higher than Brown in most drafts - and not for no reason, it's a better combo!

Answer 7

I would make the trade.

Answer 8

No Moss will have another monster year with the Pats soft schedule and their need to run up the score on teams.

I am not sold steven jackson is an elite back ... but he could prove me wrong ...

Answer 9

NO. randy moss is the best WR in the NFL. Steven is good but after a season of playing only a few games nobody knows if he is going to be as good as he was in the past. So keep randy and ronnie. Ronnie is not a bad RB but he does start.