Should i trade a-rod,michael young and johnathen papelbon for Chipper Jones, José Reyes, and mariano riveria?

Question

Should i trade a-rod,michael young and johnathen papelbon for Chipper Jones, José Reyes, and mariano riveria?

Answer 1

NOOOO !!!!!

Answer 2

I wouldn't make this deal. The only way I'd do this trade is if you replaced Jose Reyes. I like the guy but he isn't having a great year. Get a good replacement for him and it should be a pretty fair trade. Chipper Jones is hitting well this year!

Answer 3

No, that would not be very bright

Answer 4

No because arod and michael young for chipper and reyes would be fair. But papelbon for rivera is totally not fair for you.Try trading arod and young for chipper and reyes. Then do a separate deal including papelbon for rivera and a second player to put in a weak spot in your lineup. If you don't have a weak spot don't do this deal. I have arod and young and i traded them for volquez and hanley ramirez.If hanley and volquez are on the same team in your league try proposing that deal. If hanley and volquez are not on the same team in your league trade michael young for volquez and hanley ramirez for arod. HOPE this helps!!!!

Answer 5

Yes, make that deal.