Should i trade chase headley and dice k for jimmy rollins?

Question

i dont have a shortstop on my team right now. i can either pick up mike aviles, erick aybar or someone else, or do this trade

Answer 1

hmmm its a hard one,i say its not fair so no keep the 2

Answer 2

Not knowing what your roster or league looks like makes this tough to answer, but I find it hard to imagine a league in which I wouldn't pull this trade; especially if I had a big hole at SS.  Headley is a decent prospect and Dice K brings good K numbers and good W numbers, but he hasn't looked durable or consistent in his time in the MLB.  Jimmy is at the top of the best lineup in baseball, playing in a band-box.  Take the trade.