Should i veto a trade of Berkman/Spilborghs for Atkins/Miggy?

Question

Berkman and Miggy are pretty much even, yet Atkins is a top 40 player and Spilborghs isn't even a regular everyday player. Shouldn't I make the Spilborghs owner offer something a little better? Or should I let it be?

Answer 1

Definitely don't veto it.

Berkman: 63 R, 19 HR, 57 RBI, 11 SB, .358 AVG

Cabrera: 34 R, 10 HR, 42 RBI, 1 SB, .284 AVG

Going by this year's stats they are far from even, and that is what the person getting Berkman is thinking.

As long as both players are making the trade in a legitimate effort to improve their team you should never veto a trade. There is no reason the commissioner's opinion is any better than any other manager.

Answer 2

This guy threw in Spilborghs to merely make it 2 for 2. This trade actually makes sense to me. one guy is prob upgrading at 1st or OF while the other needed a 1B or 3B. I have made trades that on paper look uneven but when you look at team needs it was a great move. Good Luck don't veto