Should the Palestianian Refugees be resettled in the Jordan Valley?

Question

- It is the same size as Greater Tel Aviv (Population 3.5 Million)

-Others can go around Ramallah, they can move into new suburbs.

- And the rest can go to evacuated settlements.

Answer 1

I have a better Question!

Why cant the Jews of Israel go back to Europe where they came from? with this, the Palestinians could go back to the land of there forefathers, and there wont  be Any Palestinian refugee problem!

Answer 2

Yes, this is a good idea.  It is unfair to dump them into Israel.  The North African and Arab Jews kicked out of their historical homelands should receive financial compensation and the return of property and assets as well.

Answer 3

The Jordan Valley and the West Bank are already crowded with Palestinians. However, this is the current plan for a Palestinian State. The trouble is, Palestinian Arabs live all over Israel and the Middle East now, so a true Homeland is almost impossible to negotiate. It's kind of like trying to recreate Greater Armenia, which would include Eastern Turkey, or Macedonia, which is in three countries now.

Answer 4

Ah,a mass expulsion based on ethnicity. I wonder who that sounds like.

No,they shouldn't. They should have a revolution and regain their ancestral homeland.

Answer 5

Should the French be resettled in Germany?

Should the South Africans be resettled in Congo?

No, They have their homeland to live in like any other nation on this planet.

So do the Palestinians.

Pray to a day when this world feel their suffering and treat them like humans

Answer 6

I starred this as a good question hours ago. I can't answer your question, sorry.  

The problem of refugees and resettlement cannot be addressed until suicide belt/virgin in paradise terrorism issue is solved.  

The problem is not with settlement, because they have Gaza for 3 years now.  The problem is the violence that emanates from it.

You tried.  Keep the star for effort.

Answer 7

Palestinians and Jordanians could have a confederation and they could even invite Syria and Iraq--which is all the more reason for Israel to be in the E.U.--as far away from them as possible!

Answer 8

No. jewish refugees should be resettled in Turkey.

Answer 9

Shlomo,

They don't want to live in Jordan.  If they did, they would have left a long time ago.  They want Israel and they want to call her Palestine - not going to happen.

Palestinians are "refugees " by their own volition.  They could have adapted very nicely and had a nice life right here, had they not tried to destroy Israel when she became a state.  Those who did accept Israel now have Israeli passport and freedom to live in peace.

Sincerely,

Ms. Miche ; })

Answer 10

Why don't they just annex it and give Palestinians the same rights as Israelis.  Sometimes I think that idea that Israel has to represent a Jewish state holds back both of the people.  Perhaps secularize it like they do in America.  Segregation didn't work in America--- it didn't work in South Africa; and walls didn't work in communist eastern Germany; walls didn't even work for the chinese and the mongolians or between the Americans and the Mexicans or Cubans or Irish. Just tear down the walls.