Should this previous question get an award

Question

How do I stop my son from dating a woman with small b*****s?

Come on 53 answers and hasn't been deleted yet.

In regards to a troll question, how would you rate it?. 1 thru 10 with ten being the best.

http://answers.yahoo.com/question/?qid=20080810112152AAyz6mH

Answer 1

Haven't laughed so hard in ages. Brilliant 10/10

He shud definately consider pooling some money to finance a boob job lol

Answer 2

Regardless of rating, successful troll is indeed successful.

I give it an 9 for execution, and a 10 for reaction.

Answer 3

I'd have to say a 10. This score  is based on how long I laughed after reading the question.  :)

Answer 4

i would rate it 7.9

Answer 5

Well, I agree that it's laughable and misguided, but I certainly don't have the authority to qualitatively assess any question.  Questions are not privy to qualitative analysis, to the extent that the question is genuinely seeking an answer.  Answers, however, are subject to qualitative analysis.  Some answers can be simply inaccurate, whilst others can be potentially harmful.

The proper formulation of a question, on the other hand, is critical and is something that seems to be a problem, particularly in the G&WS forum.  For example, in formulating a question, there should not be an inherent false premise that needlessly places the answerer in a defensive posture.  This would constitute an objectable question in legal terms.

Here's an example of what a "loaded" question is:

"Why do you continue to beat your wife with a book over the head every Tuesday evening?"

You see, the very premise of this question pre-supposes that one engages in an activity without a formal basis.  If I don't engage in this behaviour, then there's no way I can answer such a question reasonably.  I can't say it's a dumb question or give it a rating; I can only say that it's not a reasonable question to pose as its inherent premise is false.

If the father of this teenager is misguided, then that's his issue, but if he genuinely is seeking an answer to a question, and it's within the confines of CG/TOS, then there's no compelling reason one should answer it nor take issue with it.

I find it laughable to the point of absurdity, but beyond that, there's nothing inherent within the question that would constitute a violation of CG.  Let me be clear on this, I find it silly and likely that it's either a joke or a highly misguided individual, but it's not a loaded question nor a violation of proprietary guidelines as they pertain to the Q/A format.

Answer 6

A perfect 10 all because his son is dating a girl with raisins.

That's my name for a girl with small b*****s.  You have your apples, cantaloupe and watermelons