Should west coast eagles up and coming players be sent back to play park footy?

Question

after just 1 win all the nobrainers of fans they have thought they will be premiers next year then lose to the demons

Answer 1

Dear Jackson, Customer Service FOOL: What a silly thing to say!! Do you have any idea how many of our senior players are missing at the moment? (I am pretty sure that someone listed them a few questions ago so i am not going through it again) but you cannot field a team of youngsters each week and expect them to consistently perform at the top level without the necessary support of senior team members around them. They are just not mature enough to do this.

i also do not recall any of our supporters claiming we will win a premiership next year. The general feeling is that in a couple of seasons we will be heading north on the ladder and then in 3 or 4 years be sitting in the top half of the ladder or higher. My bad if i am wrong but i tend to read every West Coast Bashing question (I am a sucker for punishment) and answer.....

Yes it was disgraceful to lose to Melbourne, but we are not the only ones to get beaten by Melbourne this year - they have won a couple of other games I believe.

Answer 2

Get a life please!

and to answer your question, of course not!!!

Why is it that we should go? we are the only team in the history of the AFL/VFL not to get a wooden spoon and have 3 premierships in our first 20 years, i don't think any other team has been that successful, so quite frankly we should be the last team to go!!  

We have beaten: 4th - Adelaide crows, 8th - St kilda, 9th - Brisbane, 12th - Essendon. Does that mean they all should play park footy? If all the teams were of even strength there would be no competition!  I also don't recall ANY eagles supporter saying we will win the 2009 flag!! Please feel free the in lighten me!!

EDIT:

Sorry brutally honest i just checked that, they are the only team along with crows that have never gotten the wooden spoon.

Answer 3

There are so many players that are seriously injured tis season at the eagles - including about 10 premiership players, plus they loss judd cousins chick r.jones and mitch morton who is dominating at richmond..this is a rebuilding time for the eagles - giving their youngsters a go at playing afl - since the eagles have no chance at making the eight - i think worsfold is giving his younger players a go at AFL because what has he got to loose? I mean they wont make the finals.

Eagles are not tanking, they are in a state of rebuilding to a better future by giving all of their young players a go.

QUINTEN LYNCH IS HOT

Answer 4

I'm not sure what's going on at the Eagles, but I don't think they will make the top eight next year if they lose to Melbourne. Fair enough if they were tanking, but according to the supporters they aren't....

Answer 5

yes

Answer 6

"W.C.Eagles"  person, could you tell me the year in which the ADELAIDE CROWS got the wooden spoon?? i just can't remember.... refresh my memory wont you?

Answer 7

You do make a very good point but they whipped my Bombers who I was starting to have a lot of faith in only to be let down, so maybe my team should be going back to the park to play!

Answer 8

No, they shouldn't.

If that was to happen I wouldn't be able to perv on Quentin Lynch. He makes me go weak in the knees every time I watch him play.

Also David Wirrupunda is my cousin.

Answer 9

Make up your mind first we are tanking then we just aren't any good.

Answer 10

11 star players out with season ending surgery.

Shall I say anymore?

And I don't think its fair everyone picks on the Eagles when other teams have had it worse.

Answer 11

The way some teams are up and down like a railway gate relates more to the competition being even, rather than erratic form in all cases.

The WCE beat Essendon(exhausted)at home, and Melbourne, with nothing to lose literally, beat them at the MCG. It might make headlines if they beat the Dogs or Hawks, but each of these sides is rebuilding and the points could go either way.

If the WCE should go back to playing park footy, where does that put the Dogs, third on the ladder and two successive losses?

You win some.....

Answer 12

what i saw against melbourne they are more suited to cleaning park toilets

Answer 13

nooooo

Answer 14

i dont think they are even good enough for that level