Snape as Harry's dad ??????????

Question

How would you have reacted if it had turned out that Snape was Harry's dad in the end of the seventh book and Harry's resemblance to james was just a co-incidence ?

Also , does anyone know any good Fan fics with this story line in it ? Where Snape turns out to be Harry's dad ?

Thanks ! xx

Answer 1

I was really disappointed with the sixth and seventh books, actually. They were well written and Rowling wrapped up the story nicely, but I didn't like the end. I refuse to accept the last two books, and I firmly believe this fanfic.

http://www.fictionalley.org/authors/obsi...

It explains all my opinions and might convice you too. Severus is a wonderful father, and is exactly what Harry needs in the whole ordeal with Voldemort. I can't believe that he would turn out perfectly normal and not be completely traumatized, as the seventh book's epilogue suggests. He will always have relationship problems, and not just with girls. Any sort of relationship would be extremely hard on him. And Severus is the perfect person to help him with this. They are both so damaged, when you think about it. Severus about Lily, and Harry with Voldemort.

You really need to read the fanfic I linked to, it just might change your mind. And I resent that you think it would be 'starwarsish' because it certainly isn't. It's perfect. Let me know what you think of the fic. (No, I didn't write it, someone else did, and I give that person full credit for it.)

Answer 2

what if VOLDEMORT was harry's dad?! now that would be wicked..

Answer 3

It would have been a blow.But I am sorry,I don't think Harry was that deserving.Even if it had turned out that way, Snape would have never loved Harry  for he was the cause to have Lily die.It's just my opinion.

Answer 4

What? That would suck! I'd close the book.

No offense, but this inspired me to create my own ending, if you're interested:

Answer 5

that would be retarded

Answer 6

haha it would be like starwarss :]

"harry potter.. i am your fatherr"

"NOOOOOOOOO!"

haha but anyway i think itwould be really unexpected:]

Answer 7

I would have known that it was a joke because J.K. Rowling said LONG before she finished the series that, she would never do that. It's way too Star Warsish.

Answer 8

Snape or Voldemort as Harry's dad would be too star wars-esque.

I can just see the scene now.

Harry climbs out of the hole into the shrieking shack. Snape reaches his hand out to Harry and in a gurgle with a sputter of blood he says "Harry, I am your father."  Then green eyes found black and Snape was no more.

I don't think I could have finished the book, I would have been laughing too hard.

Answer 9

The seventh book is already out and that is not how it turns out.