Question:

So you want them to add 4th judge to American Idol?

by  |  earlier

0 LIKES UnLike

I didnt want them to 'cause the show was always good with the 3, its 2 late to add a 4th one because there is only 2 seasons left.

 Tags:

   Report

9 ANSWERS


  1. I don't know why they did it and it had to be because they thought they could make it a better show, but why change something when its been going fine the way it is.


  2. Canadian Idol has four so why not.

  3. I never knew they were adding a 4th. I think it would be great!! I find Paula useless as a judge. She doesn't give even half decent critiques of the performances....so it would be great to have a 3rd judge who knows how to give constructive criticism. But....you never know..maybe she is no better than Paula.

  4. NO

  5. It's not fair to prejudge the new 4th judge.  She might surprise us and be great.  Maybe it'll be better than we think.  Let's give her a chance.  It's gotta be very difficult for her to come in knowing people like the show the way it was.  I'll still watch. Luv the show.

  6. i DON'T agree in a 4th judge being added....paula's a mess sometimes and she's too positive but if it ain't broke....don't fix it!!! the show still gets millions of viewers every week!!!!

  7. I was surprised they chose another brunette.   Hopefully, she's not as ditzy as Paula.

  8. there's no need for a 4th judge!

    I can barely tolerate the 3 we have now!

  9. I know! I think they are trying to change to much! This new girl looks to much like paula! I dont think im going to like her... But you never know she may be a really good judge! =]

Question Stats

Latest activity: earlier.
This question has 9 answers.

BECOME A GUIDE

Share your knowledge and help people by answering questions.