So you want them to add 4th judge to American Idol?

Question

I didnt want them to 'cause the show was always good with the 3, its 2 late to add a 4th one because there is only 2 seasons left.

Answer 1

I don't know why they did it and it had to be because they thought they could make it a better show, but why change something when its been going fine the way it is.

Answer 2

Canadian Idol has four so why not.

Answer 3

I never knew they were adding a 4th. I think it would be great!! I find Paula useless as a judge. She doesn't give even half decent critiques of the performances....so it would be great to have a 3rd judge who knows how to give constructive criticism. But....you never know..maybe she is no better than Paula.

Answer 4

NO

Answer 5

It's not fair to prejudge the new 4th judge.  She might surprise us and be great.  Maybe it'll be better than we think.  Let's give her a chance.  It's gotta be very difficult for her to come in knowing people like the show the way it was.  I'll still watch. Luv the show.

Answer 6

i DON'T agree in a 4th judge being added....paula's a mess sometimes and she's too positive but if it ain't broke....don't fix it!!! the show still gets millions of viewers every week!!!!

Answer 7

I was surprised they chose another brunette.   Hopefully, she's not as ditzy as Paula.

Answer 8

there's no need for a 4th judge!

I can barely tolerate the 3 we have now!

Answer 9

I know! I think they are trying to change to much! This new girl looks to much like paula! I dont think im going to like her... But you never know she may be a really good judge! =]