Someone offered me J. Hamilton for A. Rios and J. Papelbon. Any reason NOT to do it?

Question

Broxton AND Torres are available on the wire, and I have SB's to give.

Answer 1

If you need saves and ERA/WHIP help then I'd say go for it.  Hamilton's going to give you more RBI's than any other player though.

Answer 2

Dont give him up, the guys on a tear all season long. He is having an MVP type year, I picked him up in my league and wouldnt give him up for the world. Rios isnt having the year he was expected to and Pap is good but dont pay for saves.

Answer 3

Any reason to post this question? I woulda accept the trade ALREADY. Go pick up Broxton (Saito is likely out for da whole season), then watch Hamilton tearing it up for ur team.

Answer 4

Do it. Broxton and Torres are really good closers, and you have stolen bases to give up. Hamilton is in a little bit of a slump, but  still, he'll give you lots of homers, RBI's, score some runs, and a good batting average. That's 4 more categories he'll give you.