Someone please help me with this huge blockbuster deal?

Question

i get josh hamilton ian kinsler and lance berkman and give up fielder soriano bj upton ludwik and eksberry. should id o it or no. my other outfielders are hollidat and magglio and i have also ryan howard but it would leave me with no bench.

Answer 1

you are getting robbed.

Answer 2

To clear the mess:

You get:

Josh Hamilton

Ian Kinsler

Lance Berkman

You give up:

Prince Fielder

Alfonso Soriano

BJ Upton

Ryan Ludwick

Jacoby Ellsbury

Don't do the trade. You realize your giving up a lot of steals. You already have HRs with Howard and Holliday and good RBIs from Ordonez. And also the players that your giving up are producing good numbers right now. I think you should stick with the players you have.

But at the same time, sell Ludwick while he's hot. Same goes with Fielder. You can get a great player from those 2.

So don't the trade, but try to sell Ludwick/Fielder.

Good luck!