Spoiler alert* Dark Knight Question?

Question

I am a big fan ive seen this move 5 times but.. I'm stuck on this dumb question because I have heard different answers from different people so now i am asking the yahoo community...

DID BATMAN KILL 5 PPL ?

Or

WAS HARVEY RESPONSIBLE?

because at the end if batman took harveys blame...wouldnt that mean that harvey killed those ppl?

anyways just give me the answer I dont need a big explantation lOL!

Answer 1

Harvey was responsible. Without a big explaination, Harvey killed those people, and yet the people needed to believe in Harvey, needed to believe in a hero, and they already saw Batman as a bad guy, so Batman took the blame

Answer 2

yes

harvey was the bad guy.

But Harvey was hope for the city

so batman took the blame

Answer 3

i believe harvey was responsible but batman took the blame so that the public eye wouldn't see how their hero (harvey) had fallen.