Sugar Shane Mosley vs Zab Judah, evenly match up?

Question

Sugar Shane Mosley vs Zab Judah, evenly match up?

Answer 1

Judah has never done what Mosley has in his career.

Answer 2

I would definately make Mosley the solid favorite.  Zab always starts off well in his fights, but then he fades- look at his fights with Floyd Mayweather, Jr. and Miguel Cotto.  Even in fights that he wins, he seems to fade toward the end: he almost lost his fight with Demarcus Corley on the scorecards because he either got tired or just got lazy toward the end of the fight.  Mosley still has a lot left, even though he is the older man- look at his fight with Miguel Cotto, in which he landed the same amount of punches as a much younger fighter in Cotto.  I see this fight going like all of Zab's other fights: he starts off fast, then fades, which is why I think Mosley will beat him by a wide points decision, similarly to how Mayweather beat Zab.  If he gets through Judah, which I think he will, I'd really like to see him get a rematch with Cotto because their first fight was really close and competitive and I'd like to see what Shane can do in a rematch.

Answer 3

Shane should take Zab with relative ease, I will be surprised if Zab goes the distance.

Answer 4

Far from even mosley is a much better fighter but judah is far from a bum and in some fights looks amazing. Zab is very inconsistent when he fights sometimes he fights very well other times not so well at all. He might be close to as fast as mosely but mosely is  a complete fighter and zab is not.

Answer 5

I think it will be competitive. Zab only has a chance if Shane has finally aged. The fighters that both fought Cotto should make it interesting. I see a late round Mosley K.O. from a nice body shot.

Answer 6

not really Sugar is way better

Answer 7

Shane Mosley impressed me in the Cotto bout, but one thing that I noticed about him is that he doesn't throw that many combinations. He has become a counter puncher and a one punch and out kind of fighter. That is going to hurt him against a fast hard hitting Judah. With that said, I think Mosely has too much a great chin and too much heart to lose to a loose cannon like Judah. Zab has become so unpredictable and unstable. Depending on Zab's confident level, This should be a great match up that I see going to decision. Mosley has power, but I don't think he has Cotto type power; and we seen that Zab can eat a few punches in his fight with Cotto. Mosley by UD.