Sunnis:Do you believe that we can find some authentic ahadith in Shia book Al Kafi?

Question

Can we find at least 10 % Sahih hadiths from Al Kafi? How can we distinguish between the Sahih ones and the fabricated ones in Al Kafi?Are Shia ahadith narrators reliable?

Answer 1

lol@pro bro he asked sunni not shia.

Answer 2

There are some narrations that are found in al-Kaafi that are Saheeh, and they are very little. They are those which are reported Tawaatur and found in the books of the Sunnah as well.

The Shee'ah do not have a proper method for Mustalah al Hadeeth. This is why many of their narrations will start with a gap of a few generations between the reporter and the narrators.

It came to a point that the Rawafidh lied so much in narrations that some of the Scholars of Hadeeth would say "رواية كوفة" "A narration from Koofah" when they were making tadh'eef (weakening the narration) because those narrations were considered Dha'eef. So even the scholars of 'Iraaq such as Imaam Ahmad were weary of narrations from Iraaq due to the lies the Rawaafidh used to invent and narrate. Shu'bah bin Hajjaaj was the first to authenticate and analyze the narrators of Basrah.

The first Shee'ee "Scholar of Hadeeth" died in the year 726H, his name was Ibn al-Mutahhir al-Hillee.

So you can see that there are centuries between the reporters of Hadeeth and the narrators in many Raafidhee books. Al-Kulaynee did not live during the time of Ja'far as Saadiq, so how can he say "I heard from Aboo Abdillaah..." and like this.

Answer 3

No, nothing about Shia is Authentic, it is a fabricated religion

Answer 4

Maybe if we look reallllly reallllllllly hard we might be able to find 1 authentic hadith.

Answer 5

they book is 99% of hadiths for their Imams !

Only 1% or less than for the prophet (and all fabricated hadiths)

yes they rank their imams more than the prophet read their book see who more metioned their the prophet or their imams !

Answer 6

It is reliable only if the same hadith is found in Sunni sources.

Keep in mind that Taqiyyah is one of the greatest virtue in shiit religion.  

Answer 7

listen man, you guys take our books and do exactly what the non-Muslims do to the Quran and take it out of context

dont sit back and think the wahabi / salafi books are all clean and authentic, cause there are loads upon loads of c**p in ur books too

oh by the way, why arent you bashing Sara X aka Love from Iran???

or do u enjoy stirring trouble between Muslims?

sister in Humanity?? she is a kaffir!  but u enjoy bashing other Muslims??

lol, wow you guys couldnt possibley get any more backwards

and jelous of what? jelous that i dont spread fitna and spread agruements and fights between Muslims?? r u kidding me?? no thanks, u keep doing that and think that is the Islamic way lol

@Heba: dont worry about fitna lovers like him, in their eyes what their doing is what Islam is all about, they would unite with kuffar and kill other Muslims rather than uniting with each other, they have showen their true dirty evil faces, nothing surprises me anymore from the ahlul fitna (wahabis)

Answer 8

sara X/love from iran(the x muslim....do you understand 'x muslim"..do you know what Islam say about people that leave islam??) are your sisters in humanity...thats good....then what are we?......are we not ur sisters in humanity?.....or does your humanity not apply to us?.......why do you carry two faces?...

your hatred towards shias is ruling your mind and heart Mr.....which is not good.....and for that reason, may Allah help you

-------

@ Pro Active

thats right....their hearts are filled with so much hatred that they would unite with kuffar only so that they can harm and bash shias...seriously.....may Allah guide these people

Answer 9

here is ALKAFI

http://www.al-shia.com/html/eng/books/ha...