TIVO verses Comcast DVR?

Question

I just got an HDTV and upgraded to a comcast digital cable box in order to receive the HD channels. I now have DVR with the new comcast box, but I also have a TIVO (not HD though). Is it worth the 300 clams to buy an HD Tivo, or should I stick with Comcast's DVR?

Answer 1

Personally, I hate the comcast DVRs.  I had so many problems with mine that I finally had to get rid of it and got tivo.  I've been very happy with my tivo service and expect to keep it for awhile.