Terrell Owens for Reggie Wayne and Jay Cuttler?

Question

This is being offered to me in my 10-team league. What's your opinion? Should I do it?

I GET:

Reggie Wayne

Jay Cuttler

I TRADE AWAY:

Terrell Owens

Here's the rest of my team:

QB - Aaron Rodgers

WR - Terrell Owens

WR - Plaxico Burress

WR - Dwane Bowe

RB - Clinton Portis

RB - Jamal Lewis

TE - Kellen Winslow

K - Adam Vinatieri

DEF - Seattle

BENCH

LenDale White

Ray Rice

Ladell Betts

Hines Ward

Anthony Gonzalez

Jason Campbell

What do you think?

Answer 1

Accept the trade before he changes his mind.  You win in this trade.

Answer 2

I'd take it.  Wayne and TO aren't really that far apart, plus you never know when TO will return to the old TO.  Throw in Cutler who should have a pretty good year and you've got a good deal on your end.  Plus you might want some extra QB depth.  I like Rodgers, but your putting all your hopes on a guy whos only really played in 1 game.....and got hurt.....  Campbell is horrible.  

Answer 3

You need the QB help, and Wayne and Owens arent really that much different statistically.

Take this.

Answer 4

yea da Good Mane Reggie Gonna Have a good Yea Dont no bout Jay doe

Answer 5

It's obvious you need help at QB and Wayne isn't that much of a downground. I would probably do the trade if this is the best you think you can get at QB. Cutler could turn out to be a top 10 QB.  

Answer 6

I dont know, I don't like it...

Marvin Harrison is back, so Reggie Wayne could potentially lose a lot of value if Harrison gets back to his old routine. Plus, Peyton is coming off an injury, which shouldn't be too much of an issue but is still potentially problematic for Wayne's value.

TO, on the other hand, is the clear #1 in Dallas and has a lot of chemistry with Romo, who only seems to be improving at QB. TO should be in the top 10 overall players again this year, no question.

Jay Cutler is an all right option at QB, but not really good enough to trade for. He's someone that I would think, in most leagues, should act as no more than a good back up and possibly even be a free agent. Chances are if this guy is willing to trade him away, he is eventually going to drop him for bench space anyways.

On the other hand, Aaron Rodgers should be a decent option at QB and possibly a big sleeper because of his WRs (Jennings and Driver have the highest average yards after the catch in the league), and the fact that GB wouldn't be so adamant about starting him over Farvre if they didn't have a lot of faith in his abilities. I would at least wait a week or 2 to see what Rodgers is capable of before panicking about having him as your primary QB.

Answer 7

I'd definitely take it. Reggie Wayne is probably going to be even better this year than last year because of the injury to Harrison. In addition Cutler, once Marshall comes back to play, will be a great QB especially if he clicks with tight end Tony Scheffler. He probably will turn out as your top QB especially if Rodgers doesn't pick his game up.  

Answer 8

I would take that without hesitating.

Answer 9

yea you need help at QB, but not as much as you think. i think aaron rodgers will actually be pretty decent this year. IMO he might even come near the numbers favre will throw in the AFC east this year. But campbell is going to struggle MIGHTILY trying to learn the west coast offense in the NFC east. wayne for TO is basically a push, although your RBs are alittle suspect, if you could work in a trade (maybe add portis to get another number 1 RB i would do it) it might make all the difference.  

Answer 10

Take it