The Outsiders 2009, easy 10 points, tell me what you think of the cast, especially Dally?

Question

Im not saying the Outsiders will be remade and it probablly shouldnt, but tell me if you like THIS cast if the movie was remade. This is to test me if I could do this profession. Thanks to all the people who have helped me make my descions. Tell me what you think, thanks!

Ponyboy: Emile Hirsch

Dally: Matthew Saldivar go to http://youtube.com/watch?v=uW7-Hs7V53U (he plays Kenickie, start at 0:54)

Johnny: Liam Aiken

Darry: Joaquin Phoenix

Sodapop: Max Crumm(hes in the same video as Matt but comes in at 4:50)

Two-Bit: Shia LaBeouf

Steve: Joseph Gordon Levitt

Bob: Ashley Parker Angel

I DO NOT WANT YOUR OPINION ON IF IT SHOULD BE REMADE OR NOT, I JUST WANT TO KNOW IF YOU WOULD LIKE THIS CAST. I KNOW I'VE ASKED THIS ALOT BUT IM WITH BINDER CASTING AND THIS IS A WAY TO MAKE SURE IF I CHOOSE THE RIGHT CAST FOR ANYTHING.

Answer 1

Except for Liam Aiken for Johnny I like your choices.  Liam just looks too young to play that part.  He might actually make a better Ponyboy.  Maybe if you switched the characters you have for Ponyboy and Johnny around.  But who would you cast as Cherry?