This is a hard trade that i need help with who getting the better of the deal?

Question

Send Adrian Peterson, Min RB from RB to Brown

Send Maurice Jones-Drew, Jac RB from RB to Brown

Receive Tom Brady, NE QB from Brown to Bench

Receive Brandon Jacobs, NYG RB from Brown to Bench

Answer 1

Brady for Peterson = good trade

Jacobs for MJD = balanced

Brady / Jacobs wins

Answer 2

this is a tough one cuz u r letting go of 2 very good rbs but u r getting a superb qb nd a average rb. it all depends on ur depth of ur rbs. if u have really good depth and ur bench can replace the loss of adrian peterson and maurice then go 4 it, but if u have weak rbs lefts and a really good qb, then dont trade because it might hurt u.

Answer 3

i think that this is a good trade.......

this is a balance and a fair trade........

i think tom brady is clearly  better than other qb......

but with adrian peterson (min) with his young career i think a lot more could happen with adrian peterson's career.......

hey but who knows what will happen......

but i like tom brady and brandon jacobs better..........

Answer 4

its tough because brady is consistent but until last year didnt have alot of yards and tds just consistency. whats the chances of moss acting like a professional 2 yrs in a row? AP will put up big numbers IF he stays healthy. did he finish a complete year with out injury in college after his freshman yr he has already been hurt once by the big boys.  but brandon jacobs isnt real great, bradshaw will probably be there primary back.

Answer 5

It would be helpful to know who else you got but you would be getting the single best player in fantasy (Brady) which makes the deal seem like a good one to me.

Answer 6

I think this is a terrible trade for you.

Adrian Peterson is going #1 or #2 overall in drafts.  Tom Brady is going between #3 and #10.  Therefore, it's safe to say that Peterson is more valuable.

MJD is also being drafted ahead of Brandon Jacobs.

So, you're losing on both players.  I think this is a bad trade for you at face value.  As always, however, it depends on your roster.  If you have a couple of other stud RBs (LT, Steven Jackson, Westbrook, Addai), then this might be ok.

I wouldn't do it.

Answer 7

When trading major pieces like that, we need alittle more info like who is on your roster.  I don't know how crazy I would be with having Jacobs as my #1 running back though.

Answer 8

You're sending one risk with huge potential (AP) and getting one with medium potential but still the high risk (Jacobs).  But Brady is solid and is less likely to get injured than any RB.  I guess if it were me I would keep AP and MJD.  With those two that's a very important position that you have locked down.