Thoughts on this Fantasy Football trade.....?????

Question

In this particular league, we start 2 team DEF and have 2 flex positions.

I get: L. Maroney (NE) and Tennessee DEF

They get: D. McFadden (OAK) and Seattle DEF

My other defense is New England, and they have the same bye week as Seattle, so I was trying to get a decent defense in return for Seattle to fix the bye week problem.

But when reviewing this trade, please base your opinions on this year's projected stats and value only.

So who wins this trade and why? Best answer gets 11+ points.

Answer 1

that was a pretty good trade it should end up working out in your favor.  

Answer 2

Maroney will have about equal or less fantasy points as Sammy Morris. McFadden doesn't have a line to defend him and they will be throwing a lot since they will be behind. I do not see how this trade would benefit you.

Answer 3

I love that trade.   You can't expect McFadden to do anything crazy this year, they have only a mediocre offensive line, and i dont see him getting even a thousand yards on the season on the ground.  I expect maroney to come in with about 8-10 TD's and get a solid amount of carries.  

also, if you go straight up, i like tennessee's defensive vs. seattle's in a fantasy league.  I think youre winning on both parts of this deal.   forget mcfadden and expect a big year for Maroney.   GOOD DEAL