Tim sylvia vs. semmy shcilt?

Question

in a cage or in a ring doesnt matter.

Answer 1

It would be interesting, since it would be the first time Tim would be looking up at his opponent.  Both have lost to the true elite in the division in Noguiera and Fedor. Semmy went the distance with Fedor but never really threatened him, and Sylvia never even go the chance to get going.

Point Schilt

Sylvia was winning the Noguiera fight till he was tapped in the 3rd and he Semmy didn't do much in his 1st round loss to Big Nog

Point Sylvia

Both are explosive strikers with tremendous range, but I think the difference would be Sylvia's skill on the ground, with him winning via submission in the 2nd round

Winner Sylvia

Answer 2

I would probably give it to Semmy he is a better striker then Tim and is also better on the ground then Tim.  Tim has only subbed two people very early in his career Semmy has subbed people with genuine BJJ moves.  Semmy got this one because he is more well rounded.