Tom Brady, Adrian Peterson or La Dalian Tomlison...?

Question

I'm in a keeper league, and can only keep 2 of these guys. Which one would you drop? and why?

Answer 1

Brady would be my drop he is good bait to drop. LT as much as I hate to say is should run all over the AFC West (broncos fan) and AD doesn't look like he has to tough of a schedule Brady is a little easier to replace with mcnabb or rodgers or cutler.

Answer 2

Drop AD and keep LT and Brady...{reason}__][AD has injury Problems!

Answer 3

Oooh tough question . . . it is so hard to drop Brady given he was the best player in fantasy last year especially given his difference between the second best qb. That having been said RB is still the most important position and it would be hard to rationalize dropping either of the other guys. I would definitely try to snag turner and taylor though if you go that route.

Answer 4

Brady for sure, no way he will have another 50 TD season. Having 2 solid RBs is much better.

Answer 5

that is a really tough one. i would probably drop Tom Brady because he wont be able to have that good of year again and i could see both LT and AD getting even more points because of lousy or aging defense in their divisions. Brady could be replaced by another QB a lot quicker before LT or AD by another RB.

And if you didnt win your league last year than that is hard to believe

Answer 6

It's a tough call, I don't think you could go wrong with any 2 of these guys.  The concern with Peterson is obviously his health and the fact that until the vikings can actually pass the ball, the D will stack up against him.  Take a look at his last couple of games of last year.  Brady will be consistent as will Tomlinson, but Tomlinson is getting up in age.  I'd take Brady and Tomlinson.  Too many questions on Peterson's health and his ability to continue to carry the Vikes.  Brady will throw TDs, as long as Moss is there, and Tomlinson rarely gets hurt and sits out preseason games; therefore there is a lot less wear and tear on him.

Answer 7

go for adrian or ladlian cuz u can always get a good qb next pick like ben rothlesburger

Answer 8

Boy that is a nice problem to have, but that doesn't make it any easier of a decision. I would have to drop Brady because that leaves you with the top 2 RB's in the league, and you could probably get a nice QB in the draft or trade for one with your stacked team down the road.

Answer 9

Wow! Tough call. I guess I would drop Peterson because he is injury prone.

Answer 10

AD and LT. Have you seen who are the top 2 picks in most drafts?

No QB should be taken in the 1st round. Brady's value is sky rocket because of his career year, he will start spreading the ball again this season and put good but not last season numbers.

Answer 11

peterson because of his knee it could be a problem down the road